| 125 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Paul Bewak | Johns Hopkins | | 2. | Jeremy Dombrady | Baldwin Wallace | | 3. | Drew Smith | Ohio Valley | |
| 133 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Corey Brown | Thiel | | 2. | Marcus Chevres | Apprentice School | | 3. | Jake Vitolo | Waynesburg | |
| 141 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Paul Marcello | Johns Hopkins | | 2. | Duncan Crystal | Johns Hopkins | | 3. | Wayne Black | College of Mt. St. Joseph | |
| 149 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Vincent Digravio | Mercyhurst NE | | 2. | Kyle Spruill | Apprentice School | | 3. | Joe Conrad | College of Mt. St. Joseph | |
| 157 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Garrett Johnston | Waynesburg | | 2. | Tommy Fehring | College of Mt. St. Joseph | | 3. | Jacob Kondrlik | Mercyhurst NE | |
| 165 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Michael Pavasko | Penn State Greater Allegheny | | 2. | Tyler George | Ohio Valley | | 3. | Cory Disbennett | College of Mt. St. Joseph | |
| 174 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Jacob Lowry | Thiel | | 2. | Ryan Walters | Waynesburg | | 3. | Nick Manning | College of Mt. St. Joseph | |
| 184 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Cody Catalina | Waynesburg | | 2. | Collins Nitcheu | Mercyhurst NE | | 3. | Anthony Bonaventura | Waynesburg | |
| 197 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Patrick Morris | Thiel | | 2. | Patrick Jennings | Waynesburg | | 3. | Luke Weber | Muskingum | |
| 285 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Brandon Fedorka | Waynesburg | | 2. | Martin Kisla | Waynesburg | | 3. | Ian Jones | Apprentice School | |